Cult of Pedagogy Search

Power Lesson: Note-Taking Stations

December 16, 2018


Peg Grafwallner

Close

Can't find what you are looking for? Contact Us


Listen to the interview with Peg Grafwallner and Abby Felten (transcript):

Sponsored by Peergrade and Microsoft Hacking STEM


 

In this power lesson shared by instructional coach Peg Grafwallner, students rotate between four stations to practice different note-taking styles.

 


 

In my work as an instructional coach and reading specialist at Ronald Reagan IB high school, a large, diverse urban school in Milwaukee, I support teachers in all content areas and help them to seamlessly embed literacy skills in their lessons.

Peg Grafwallner, Instructional Coach

Abby Felten is one of our chemistry teachers at Reagan. Abby noticed that her sophomore students had extremely limited experience in reading a science textbook. As a result, their note-taking skills were inadequate when trying to gather information from the text. We decided to create a structured lesson that utilized stations to give students an opportunity to practice with various types of note-taking styles.

Abby Felten, Chemistry Teacher

Gathering the Resources

I gathered three types of note-taking templates: a concept map, a Doug Buehl-inspired graphic organizer called a magnet summary, and Cornell notes; along with annotation, these would make up the four stations.

At each station, we set up a completed example of that type of template so students could see how it’s done. To create the examples, we used pages from the students’ chemistry textbook. Abby chose one small section for each template along with a page for annotation, and I made one copy of the designated pages. She didn’t give me any directions or a quick lesson in basic chemistry; instead, it was up to me to figure out which template worked best for each page.

I decided to use Cornell notes for the page with the most text. The Cornell template lent itself to text where the notes could be neatly arranged, writing key words or questions on the left side and definitions or brief phrases on the right side.

Cornell Notes
(These photos show student work, not the teacher-generated examples.)

 

Next, I chose the concept map for the pages with pictures and text. I wrote the main idea of the text in the middle box and used the surrounding boxes for details or formulas.

Concept Map

 

For the magnet summary template, I also used pages with pictures and text. Again, I wrote the main idea in the middle box and the details in surrounding boxes. Then I wrote a brief summary using the middle box as my topic sentence, and the surrounding boxes as sentence details.

Magnet Summary

 

Finally, I annotated the page with the most pictures and formulas, asking questions, making comments, or circling unknown vocabulary in the margins.

Annotation

 

I shared my completed note-taking templates along with the annotated page with Abby. After her review, we put the pages in plastic sheets to use as exemplars at each station.

Implementation

In this particular sophomore class, Abby had about 25 students sitting at traditional science tables. Students were given four new pages to annotate or take notes on. We didn’t want them to take notes on the pages I had used for my examples; rather, we wanted them to try four new pages from the text, but use the exemplars as visual representations.

We created four stations: one for each of the four note-taking styles, along with several blank copies of the template. At the annotation station, we made several copies of the chemistry page that students were expected to annotate. We decided students would spend approximately 15 minutes at each station, including time to read the corresponding section from their chemistry text.

Abby described the directions and purpose for the lesson. She clarified that she wanted to introduce students to various note-taking templates in addition to them practicing different types. I offered brief directions for each template, demonstrating how to use each one with the exemplars.

Finally, Abby set the timer. Students began reading the information in their chemistry books and reviewing the exemplars at their tables. Next, they grabbed blank note-taking templates and began to write their notes. Abby and I walked around the room, observing what students were writing. We encouraged students to work together, to talk to each other and see how their peers were writing their notes.

Students work at the annotation station.

 

After 15 minutes, the timer went off and students rotated to the next station. For the first couple of minutes, the room was silent as students read the page assigned to that station. Then the room filled with chatter as students reviewed the exemplar, wrote their notes and shared their information. At the magnet summary station, we noticed students sharing their summaries and verifying that they were similar.

Student Debrief

After students had visited all four stations, we gave them time to debrief with their peers about the lesson, then we asked their opinions.

 

Students work at the concept map station.

Teacher Reflection

Abby and I felt that this lesson was a success. Since giving the lesson, she has seen explicit improvements in the ways her students approach reading and taking notes. Those improvements include:

  1. Their notes are neater, more organized and meaningful. Students aren’t just rewriting the text—they are adding their own thoughts, questions and images into their notes. They’re taking pride in their notes.
  2. Students are varying their own note-taking styles to match the style of text. They’re creating concept maps when the class covers topics that are interconnected and not so linear, using Cornell notes when learning scientific theories and linear processes, and drawing out their ideas and processes instead of writing everything out.
  3. Students are actually using their notes! They are editing and revising their notes as the class does more practice and examples. Notes aren’t just a thing they have to do in class anymore. Students are using them to review.
  4. Students are more engaged with a text. Abby has found that she needs to limit the quantity of text that she asks them to read and take notes on to encourage this, but she’d rather take quality over quantity, especially at the sophomore level. Their comprehension of the information they have read has increased, as has the depth of their questions in class.
  5. Students can synthesize information more readily. One of the extension activities that Abby has done after the note-taking stations is having them consolidate a full unit of notes to a single page—front and back—of a graphic organizer or plain paper. This synthesis of information is now significantly easier and more meaningful for them.

Finally, as an instructional coach, I have shared this lesson, with content modifications, in other disciplines and with all student abilities. The opportunity for student ownership and the chance to choose is what makes this lesson timeless and engaging—exactly what our students need for success! ♦

 


Resources:

Buehl, D. (2017). Classroom Strategies for Interactive Learning. New York, NY: Stenhouse Publishers.

(The above is an Amazon affiliate link. Cult of Pedagogy receives a small commission on any purchase made when visiting Amazon through this link at no extra cost to you.)


 

Come back for more.
Join our mailing list and get weekly tips, tools, and inspiration that will make your teaching more effective and fun. You’ll get access to our members-only library of free downloads, including 20 Ways to Cut Your Grading Time in Half, the e-booklet that has helped thousands of teachers save time on grading. Over 50,000 teachers have already joined—come on in.

 

24 Comments

  1. Kelly says:

    I can’t wait to modify this for my 8th grade ELA 45 minute classes!

  2. Barbara says:

    This is a great lesson! I think I would add some sort of hanging-indent note taking so students have another way to think about taking down main idea and supporting detail(s).

    As I think about this year’s students (middle school), I wonder whether many of them would be able to handle that much handwriting in one session. Increasingly, I find that students cannot or will not write by hand, even printing; they want to keyboard exclusively. This year I’ve had several protest taking notes by hand. I’d be interested to know what others are seeing, how they’re addressing this (if they are), and how this lesson might be adapted to incorporate less handwriting. (Don’t misunderstand–the lesson is great, and ideally I will/would teach it as written! I’m just thinking ahead…)

    • Hi Barbara,
      While I certainly hear you, you might want to share this article w/ them about the advantages in taking notes by hand (https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/a-learning-secret-don-t-take-notes-with-a-laptop/ and https://www.npr.org/2016/04/17/474525392/attention-students-put-your-laptops-away). My recommendation: Start w/ two stations, instead of four, and introduce w/ a relevant paragraph from a current article or maybe even an example from their school newspaper. Take it slow…but take it! Good luck!

    • Jane Hunn says:

      I have several students who are really getting into SketchNoting, and that has improved the quality and quantity of notes being taken. Some every artistic students are finding their “voice” through art.

      • Hi Jane,
        Thank you for this wonderful suggestion. We need all kinds of choices for our students, and using SketchNotes is a great example of another choice.

    • Daniel Powers says:

      Hi Barbara,

      As a high school type thinking about next steps for my students, I am always worried about what they will see in college. I have three of my own in college now and they confirm that many exams are handwritten events. Some of my students have very poor handwriting and I fear that they will be at a disadvantage if prof’s or TA’s aren’t willing or able to put in the time to figure out what they have written. Letting my students know this has been effective for me when I have encountered handwriting protests!

  3. Allysa Fite says:

    I love this post! I’ve been using stations in my secondary classroom for many years and it is a lot of work up front to prepare but so worth it for the outcome. My favorite lesson with stations was written by me and a coach as well. It was intended to help students with perspectives from the trail of tears. It included complex narratives, paintings, maps and videos and it was one of the best lessons I ever “taught” because students were engaged in the material like never before. One additional strategy for stations specifically is that I structure my groups strategically by ability level. I make a few groups mixed with “high achieving” and “middle” kids and then one or two groups with “middle” and “low achieving” students. That way I can focus my support with those students who need more clarification, scaffolding, redirection, etc. and that has been really helpful. In other activities, heterogenous grouping is better, but for this instructional method I believe more homogenous groups worked best.

  4. Rebeca says:

    I am very surprised about not having students doing this in everylesson.Learning how to take notes should be taught from MS but teachers are getting lost in making all fun projects and we are losing the essence of learning and processing knowledge we want to please kids and taking notes imply effort and concentration if we don’t teach this we are not doing a favour to our future. For me was a must in my grade 6 science class. if a student read but and is not able to indentify the key words of the text then that student does read but not comprehend. Old school note taking forget technology. Thank you for your post cultofpedagogy.com

    • Hello Rebeca,
      Thank you for your comment. It is important to teach note-taking in all grades (beginning w/ elementary), but it can be done in various ways. Hopefully, this article helps teachers to be cognizant of the value of note-taking skills and how all students can learn how to take good notes, regardless of what grade they are in.

  5. Robert Ward says:

    What I love most about this is the Student Debrief section. Peg and Abby give the students voice and choice in what is effective for their individual learning. This is also an article about instructional coaching at its best. Peg expertly guides the teacher so Abby can in turn deftly guide her students. If you want more practical and wise advice, check out Peg’s new book, Lessons Learned from the Special Education Classroom. Her wisdom has transformed my teaching!

    • Thank you, Robert, for your kind words. The only way we get better as educators is by collaborating for the sake of our students. This lesson specifically demonstrates the value of collaboration and when done well, creates an opportunity for choice, voice and vigor (no more rigor!) for our kids.

  6. Saba Ansari says:

    Love this idea and cannot wait to share it at my school. I work at an inner city school and my kiddos get burnt out trying to write stuff down. Some either write everything and others, nothing at al!

    Thank you‼️👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

    • Hello Saba,
      Yes, I hear you. Please let me know how I can help. I’d be happy to share some ideas w/ you in getting them ready for note-taking (annotation always comes first).
      Thank you!

      • Saba Ansari says:

        Hello Peg

        I was wondering if you could share an exemplar for annotation that I could use with my on-level Physics kiddos. I have all levels of students from freshmen to seniors in my physics classes.

        Thank you!

  7. stacey says:

    I am just wondering if you can clarify a little bit between the magnet summary and the concept map. What would be the main difference in the notes that are written in the graphic organizer between these two methods?

  8. Hi Stacey,
    Thank you for the question. The difference is the summary. With a concept map, students can create their own “bubbles” of inquiry/comments/brainstorming (the one I used is visually similar to the MS). Encourage students to create their own concept map so they’re not limited by the # of boxes. Regarding the MS, students find the main idea (the middle box) and four details. Then when they write their summary, the main idea is the topic sentence and the four boxes are the corresponding details. Good luck and let me know how I can help.

  9. Naadia Owens says:

    This lesson is so awesome! During my ongoing teacher evolution, I have realized that students need support learning how to take notes every year. New class, new teacher, they need help getting back into the swing of things and some direct note-taking instruction has really helped and I’m always thrilled by how much my students appreciate when I go over notetaking. I love when they reference their improvement in their portfolios! Something else I’ve been trying to do this year is (1) post notetaking videos and tips/tricks to schoology so that when I read their notes and they look rough I can recommend videos for them to watch (2) using notetaking techniques in our in-class activities. So if I am going to have them listen to a podcast instead of saying “take notes” pushing myself to have them watch a short Cornell notes video before for review and then practice taking Cornell notes while we listen to the podcast. It’s pushed me to stop reinventing the wheel 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.