Cult of Pedagogy Search

How to Teach When Everyone is Scattered

Close

Can't find what you are looking for? Contact Us


Listen to this post as a podcast:

Sponsored by Teaching Channel and UL Xplorlabs


 

Let’s go back for a moment to a simpler time, back to 2019 when you may have “struggled to differentiate.” When you tried to meet the needs of all students who came to you with different levels of readiness, who had different physical, emotional, and cognitive profiles, and who learned best under different scenarios.

2020 laughs at 2019. 

Teaching is much more complicated now, and you are most likely in a situation where your students are scattered in some way. It may be one or a combination of these:

Before, a teacher only had to worry about meeting students where they were academically, socially, and emotionally. Now you literally have to figure out a way to meet them where they are.

Depending on who’s running your school, you may be expected to do any number of instructional gymnastics to keep all of these students engaged and on track. While I’m not going to get into the “shoulds” here (I address some best practices in this post, and I ranted about one specific remote teaching problem in this Facebook live broadcast), what I’d like to do in this post is curate some of the ways teachers have solved the problem of teaching students who are literally all over the place. 

I pulled these ideas from responses to two separate tweets: In the first one, I asked what was working when teaching some students in person and others at home. The second tweet came a few weeks later, where I was asking specifically for strategies to build community among all the scattered groups. I got hundreds of responses, some of which I was still trying to digest an hour ago, so this list is just a sampling of some of the ideas I saw repeated several times and a few that I thought were really noteworthy. If you want to see all of the ideas, follow those links and enjoy! I’ll warn you though, it’s a lot. With so many people working on the same problem at the same time, there are a lot of ideas in many different iterations. My goal here is to pare it down to just a few that I think you can use.

(One more thing: For efficiency, I’m going to refer to all videoconferencing software as Zoom. So when I say “Zoom,” just know that this means Google Meet, Microsoft Teams video, Skype, or whatever you’re using. It’s just faster this way.) 

1. Create Student Cohorts

This was the most frequently mentioned piece of advice from teachers doing this work, so I’m putting it first and separating it from everything else. 

The idea is to put students into groups that span different populations—some virtual, some F2F, some from different days in an A/B schedule—so they can help each other through your course. Doing this allows students to ask each other questions and support each other at times when you’re not available. It’s also a way to create connections between your in-class students and those who are learning from home. 

2. Limit the Synchronous

Many teachers are finding that synchronous instruction—where all students in class and at home are plugged in and participating in real time—needs to be very limited and used intentionally, as opposed to just recording an entire class session and expecting everyone to sit through that. (Again, I explored the ridiculousness of this idea here.).

Here are some ways this principle is playing out:

3. Chunk the Time

It can be tremendously helpful to break up the class period into designated chunks, where some students are learning directly from the teacher, others are working in groups, and others are working independently. If you can make the structure visible and predictable for students, even better. The two resources listed below can help you imagine what those structures might look like for you. (Notice that none of the options listed have the teacher lecturing for the entire period. That’s important.)

 
Courtesy of Beth Alexander. All models available in this PDF.
 
Courtesy of Beth Alexander. All models available in this PDF.
 

One more tip for this “chunking”: When you switch from synchronous to asynchronous, but there will be a time when you go back to synchronous, set up an on-screen timer to let at-home kids know when time is up for an activity.

4. Build Community Intentionally

Having students in multiple locations makes it much harder to build a classroom community, but those relationships are so important for making students feel a sense of belonging and connection. Here are some things teachers are doing to meet this challenge:

5. Experiment with Cameras and Screens

Lots of teachers mentioned setups that involved more than one camera and screen so that the same broadcasts can capture different things simultaneously. The number of ideas and combinations along these lines got pretty overwhelming, so I’ll just share three big ones:

6. Optimize Discussions

If your synchronous time includes class discussions that include both F2F and at-home learners, these suggestions can help you make the most of that time.

 

None of these ideas are really tested, researched, or optimized in any way, so don’t feel like this is some massive to-do list that you have to check off. If you can implement one or two strategies that make things better for you and your students, that’s a success.

Probably the worst thing you can do is to try and replicate exactly what you were doing before 2020, time-wise and content-wise. That’s trying to force a square peg into a round hole; by doing that, you’re just signing up for a ton of frustration. 

Years ago I wrote a piece urging teachers to think of your teaching as always being “in Beta.” Consider teaching in a post-COVID world to be the most massive project-in-Beta ever. It’s going to be messy, but that’s how humans learn and grow and adapt. Continue to experiment, fall apart on the days when it’s your turn (because everyone seems to need a turn every now and then), ask students and parents for feedback, observe other teachers when you can, and most importantly, keep giving yourself and your students grace.

We’re getting through this.

 

Come back for more.
Join our mailing list and get weekly tips, tools, and inspiration that will make your teaching more effective and fun. You’ll get access to our members-only library of free downloads, including 20 Ways to Cut Your Grading Time in Half, the e-booklet that has helped thousands of teachers save time on grading. Over 50,000 teachers have already joined—come on in.

 

21 Comments

  1. Shane Johnson says:

    Thanks so much, Jennifer! Your ability to synthesize while providing instantly-usable strategies is remarkable!

  2. Very valuable information!

  3. Virginia Pratt says:

    Jennifer, this is a Godsend, and it couldn’t have come at a better time. We are getting ready to start hybrid next week, with 1/2 of our F2F kids coming M/T and the other half Th/F, with a All-Virtual contingent who won’t ever come in, and we have to teach them all. This podcast gave me ideas that I think I can really use. I’ve learned much from you over the years, but I don’t think I’ve ever been so totally grateful for an episode! Thank you!

  4. Dear Jennifer,
    I am so happy I have found your page and podcast! I am a teacher in training in Germany (subjects English and Business Administration) since last November and I really love listening to your content. It has helped me to calm down a lot of times, you have given me a lot of input on how I can improve the way I teach – especially concerning digital teaching/learning! Thank you so much for all that you do…
    Love,
    Lena

  5. Thank you so much. Sharing with all my colleagues. So many wonderful ideas!

  6. Monica Knuppe says:

    I and my class have tried numerous things- sometimes I feel like I have tried everything that didn’t work. I spent a lot of time, creating the videos, one kid watched them. I used professional videos, thinking it was me…no one watched those.

    I know it is all wrong according to you, but what is working for us, is synchronous learning. Kind of like being in class. My kids really struggle with learning by themselves. It is lonely and boring.

    So just another point of view.

  7. Great streamlined list! Very accurate and timely. Thanks!

  8. Shawnette Simons says:

    I am a TA in Highschool. I am learning how to support the teachers that I support. It can be very difficult at times. Learning how to help and when.
    I encouraged the examples on how to start the class. Which gives the teacher time to do adm work.

  9. Michelle Lewis says:

    I think putting students who grasp what’s going on with students who are struggling helps all students. I spoke to the teacher I work with last week about this.

    • Tricia Kriese says:

      You mentioned putting all students on zoom. I am teaching students in person and on-line at the same time. Is there a way to group students at home with those in person? I have tried, but the feedback loop seems to make it impossible.

      Thanks!

      • Anne says:

        It works really well as long as all the students have headphones. If they don’t you get terrible feedback. We have been at it for a month now at my school and teachers and students are all getting used to the mechanics of it. I don’t use it all the time but just did this morning. It’s a nice way to do group work that includes everyone.

  10. Kristi says:

    This is a great set of ideas. I’m wondering if anyone has some specific ideas about teaching K-1 in a concurrent model, I’m really struggling with how to best do this.

  11. Fantastic post. Thank you for the great, practical, and realistic information.

  12. VinDBX says:

    Hi Jennifer!

    Thank you for the wealth of information! My students really like the Nearpod lessons and they are very engaged. I will look at adding Peardeck as well. We have also used Kahoot! Which has been great.

    My biggest struggle is wanting to setup groups, but the students are using the groups inappropriately as well as chat. Chat has been disabled school-wide due to bullying and other issues. I’ve even seen information about students using Teams to set up their own extremely inappropriate channels for friends to join. What do you suggest for these scenarios?

    • Hi! While our team has not used Microsoft Teams to any extent, we wanted to pass this article along with the hopes that it will help: Keeping students safe while using Teams for distance learning. We’d also like to suggest the importance of the students understanding the online protocols via the teacher taking time to teach them. This way, students should have an understanding of what’s expected of them as well as the consequences if the rules aren’t followed. We wish you all the best!

  13. Ann Phillips says:

    I listen to your podcast when I commute to work. I love it! However, I can’t take notes while I drive. Please tell me: who sponsored this episode? I know I heard about a company that interested me, but I can’t find it in the show notes. Do you list the sponsors somewhere on this website? Thanks; I hate to bother you anytime this happens. You have so many intriguing ideas! Thank you again!

    • Hi Ann! We’re so glad you’re enjoying the podcast. This episode was sponsored by Teaching Channel and ULXplore Labs. This info is always immediately under the featured image of the post that matches the podcast episode.
      Since you’re a podcast listener, I recommend clicking on ‘podcast’ in the top-right menu on the site and then clicking on the episode you’re interested in.
      I hope this helps!

  14. Pat M. says:

    I am so thankful that this article was on our choice board for ESP PD today. Thank you so much for the helpful suggestions. I feel like there may be hope! It’s also encouraging to see just how much the education community is coming together, sharing ideas in support of teachers and excellence in education during this season of change!
    I can’t wait to read more and play around with the ideas.

  15. Mindy Curtis says:

    This article and podcast had amazingly helpful information! As a school coach who is assisting teachers in adapting this year, but has never taught in COVID era myself, this was very, very helpful! Thanks!

  16. Sienna Compton says:

    I’m so happy that I decided to listen to this podcast today. I feel more at ease knowing that we are all struggling, but starting to see successes.

    I was also super thrilled to hear about Yoteach! I used Today’s Meet quite a bit and was bummed when I couldn’t find something comparable. Thank you for that!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.